How Managers and Leaders Can Give Constructive Feedback
Giving feedback is an art that can make or break professional relationships. When done right, it can inspire growth, foster trust, and drive positive change. When handled poorly, it can create resentment, damage morale, and hinder progress. The good news? Anyone can master the art of constructive feedback by following some fundamental principles.
The Foundation: Timing and Setting
Let's face it - nobody enjoys receiving criticism in front of their peers. The timing and setting of your feedback can significantly impact how it's received. The golden rule? Address situations promptly, but always in private. Think about it: would you want your areas for improvement broadcast across the office? Probably not.
Creating the right environment means finding a quiet space where both parties can speak openly without interruption. This isn't just about privacy; it's about showing respect and creating psychological safety for honest dialogue.
The Art of Delivery
Here's where many well-intentioned feedback sessions go off the rails - in the delivery. The key is to be specific and behaviour-focused rather than making sweeping generalisations about someone's personality. Instead of labelling someone as "unreliable," try something like, "I noticed you've missed our last three project deadlines."
The SBI (Situation-Behaviour-Impact) technique is your secret weapon here. Picture this: You're giving feedback about a team meeting. Instead of saying "You're too aggressive," try:
Situation: "During yesterday's marketing meeting..."
Behaviour: "When you interrupted Sarah three times while she was presenting..."
Impact: "It made her lose her train of thought and discouraged others from sharing their ideas."
Making It a Two-Way Street
Gone are the days of one-sided feedback sessions where managers simply lecture their team members. Modern feedback is a dialogue, not a monologue. This means actively listening to the other person's perspective and working together to find solutions.
Remember to use "I" statements to share your observations without sounding accusatory. Instead of "You always miss deadlines," try "I feel concerned when projects are delivered late because it impacts the entire team's workflow." This subtle shift in language can make a world of difference in how your message is received.
The Power of Balance and Follow-Through
Think of feedback like a healthy diet - it needs balance. Aim for a ratio of roughly three positive observations for every constructive criticism. This isn't about sugar-coating; it's about building trust and maintaining receptiveness to future feedback.
Here's the crucial bit that often gets overlooked: follow-through. End each feedback session by:
Summarising the key points discussed
Setting clear, actionable goals for improvement
Scheduling follow-up conversations to monitor progress
Expressing confidence in the person's ability to grow
Remember, the goal isn't to criticise what cannot be changed but to focus on actionable improvements that are within the person's control. Your body language and tone should convey support and genuine desire to help, not judgement or criticism.
The art of giving constructive feedback isn't mastered overnight, but with practice and the right approach, it becomes second nature. The key is to remember that effective feedback isn't about tearing people down - it's about building them up and providing them with the tools they need to succeed. After all, when done right, feedback is one of the most powerful catalysts for professional growth and development.
So next time you need to give feedback, take a moment to plan your approach. Your thoughtful delivery could be the difference between fostering growth and creating resistance. Remember, we're all in this together, working towards becoming better versions of ourselves.
Want to learn more about giving constructive feedback? Litmus helps people and teams feel in their element and communicate in a way that’s anything but neutral.
Take a look at our Services or get in touch to find out more.